ECP says PTI received 'prohibited funds' from 34 foreign nationals – The Express Tribune

Free electricity burden ‘borne by distributors’Floods damaged over 10,797 houses: report Home Latest Pakistan Business Sci-Tech Phones World Opinion Life & Style Sports Blogs Archive Other PTI issued show cause notice in prohibited funding caseThe …

Free electricity burden ‘borne by distributors’
Floods damaged over 10,797 houses: report
Home
Latest
Pakistan
Business
Sci-Tech
Phones
World
Opinion
Life & Style
Sports
Blogs
Archive
Other
PTI issued show cause notice in prohibited funding case
The Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) on Tuesday said the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) received 'prohibited funds' from 34 foreign nationals and 351 companies based outside the country.
The party was issued a show cause notice after the unanimous verdict — reserved in June earlier this year – by the three-member bench of the ECP headed by Chief Election Commissioner Sikander Sultan Raja.
"The Commission directs that a notice may be issued to the Respondent party [PTI] in terms of Rule-6 of PPR 2002, as to why the aforementioned prohibited funds may not be confiscated. The office is also directed to initiate any other action under the law, in light of this order of the Commission," said the 68-page judgement – a copy of which is available with The Express Tribune.
The electoral watchdog also declared that 13 'unknown' accounts have been found linked to the party and the submissions by PTI chief Imran Khan were 'inaccurate and wrong'.
Read: PTI directly benefited from foreign funding
“This Commission is constrained to hold that Mr Imran Khan failed to discharge his obligations as mandated under the Pakistani Statutes. The Chairman PTI has or successive five years (2008-2009 to 2012-2013) under review and examination has submitted Form-1 and signed a Certificate which is not consistent with [the] accounting information before us which has been gathered and complied on the basis of information obtained from Banks through [the] State Bank of Pakistan," said the judgement by the ECP.
“Mr Imran Khan for the five years under review has filed submissions which were grossly inaccurate and wrong. Even during the course of Scrutiny and Hearing by this Commission, PTI continued to conceal and withhold complete and full disclosure of [the] source of its funds."
Imran had personally issued certificates to the ECP in regards to Article 13(2) of the PPO to the effect that PTI “does not receive funds from prohibited sources”, meaning thereby that the PTI is not a foreign-aided political party.
The commission stated in its verdict said that the party "knowingly and willingly" recieved funding from Wootton Cricket Limited which was operated by the now jailed tycoon Arif Naqvi. The PTI was a "willing recipient" of $2,121,500.
Other foreign-based companies which donated to the party include the UAE-based Bristol Engineering Services, Cayman Island registered E-Planet Trustees, Australia-based Dunpec Limited and the UK-based SS Marketing Manchester.
The election commission, in its verdict, also stated the party violated Article 17(3) (3) of the Constitution as the PTI failed to declare three bank accounts operated by the party's senior leadership and the concealment of 16 bank accounts by the party was a "serious lapse".
'Battle between truth and strength'
The petitioner of the case, PTI founding member Akbar S Babar, spoke to the media after the verdict's announcement and thanked God and his late mother for "victory" in "this battle".
"We were fighting against a mountain. This was a battle of truth versus strength and we are victorious."
Babar stated that there was no personal benefit for him in this case, rather the nation benefitted as Pakistani politics needed a pivotal change so that political parties were tested under the law.
He thanked the ECP, stating that we [the people] had to trust and strengthen state institutions.
"We were tested many times over these past eight years but this very same election commission has agreed with all my arguments."
Reiterating the decision of the electoral watchdog, Babar maintained that the ECP had agreed that the PTI received funding from foreign individuals and companies and that several certificates submitted by Imran were "fake".
"Imran Khan used to threaten PTI, would insult the chief of the election commission and attack people personally", he claimed, adding that he believed this was "fascism".
He claimed that the ECP's decision was a step towards uprooting PTI's "fascism".
'Not a case of foreign funding'
PTI leader Farrukh Habib said that the party has maintained that "this was not a foreign funding case, this was a case about prohibited funding".
He further stated that those who propelled the narrative of the case being about "foreign funding" have been severely disappointed that the PTI was not banned today, it was only served a show cause notice.
"We will give a sufficient reply to the notice", he concluded.
Maleeka Bokhari, talking to the media after Habib, said media groups against the PTI and the coalition parties of PDM had "lost hope" today.
She claimed that the PTI was not the kind of party to accept foreign funding, however, the "propaganda" against it was furthered for years.
According to Bokhari, investigation committees were formed in 2018 to inquire into PTI funding but their reports were never made public because they proved nothing against the party. She maintained that the "biggest democratic party in Pakistan" was being pushed to the corner through a constitutional institution.
She asked PDM leaders to show their bank accounts, alleging that Benazir Bhutto had said that the PML-N felled her government with Osama Bin Laden's money and questioned why did the JUI-F had received funding from Libya's Saif al-Islam Gaddafi.
"All of this should have been done within the law, however, it is sad that these parties cannot match the PTI constitutionally and legally".
PTI's Fawad Chaudhry thanked those who fought the case for the last eight years.
"PTI is Pakistan's only party that conducts proper public funding drives. No other political party does this", the former information minister said.
He maintained that the case was about funding from 2008 to 2013 and that the PTI had collected approximately Rs3-4 billion, a major part of which came from overseas Pakistanis.
"I don't understand why PML-N, PPP, JUI have made overseas Pakistanis their enemy when we consider them the backbone of our economy", he said adding that the party will still rely on them for funding.
'Your politics have been buried'
Shiekh Rashid, a close ally of Imran, said after today the politics of PDM will be "buried". He expressed confidence that the case, if it is taken to the Supreme Court, will be done with in a single hearing.
He further said that the ECP should also decide on the funding cases of PML-N and PPP. "Nawaz Sharif took funds from al-Qaeda's Osama bin Laden."
When asked if there was any 'back-channel diplomacy', Rashid said he does not know of any such developments but politicians "never close their doors".
"Imran Khan is a popular voice of the people."
Security in the federal capital was placed on high alert before the much-awaited verdict. Extra contingents of police and riot police forces were deployed to avoid any untoward incident.
Before the verdict's announcement, PTI leader Fawad Chaudhry said the decision of the ECP will be in accordance with earlier court judgements, and the electoral watchdog will decide against the three main political parties of Pakistan – PTI, PML-N and PPP.
The former information added that political decisions "will be made by the people and not the ECP".
سپریم کورٹ اور ہائیکورٹ دونوں کے فیصلے ہیں کہ تینوں جماعتوں کے کیسز کا فیصلہ الیکشن کمیشن کرے لیکن الیکشن کمیشن نون لیگ اور پیپلزُپارٹی کے فنڈنگ معاملات کو دیکھنے کی زحمت نہیں کر رہا آج کوئ آسمان نہیں ٹوٹنا سیاسی فیصلے الیکشن کمشنر نہیں عوام نے کرنے ہیں اصل فیصلہ عوام کا ہو گا

Govt presses ECP to give verdict
The development came as constituent parties of the coalition government led by Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) had been calling upon the ECP to announce the verdict in the case at the earliest.
Leaders of the ruling coalition from the Pakistan Democratic Movement (PDM) and Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) on Friday met senior officials of the ECP, including the chief election commissioner (CEC), in an effort to convince the electoral body to announce its verdict reserved in the prohibited funding case involving the PTI.
Addressing a news conference after the meeting, PML-N leader and former prime minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi said that the joint delegation spoke with the ECP officials, urging them to “decide the case of prohibited foreign funding as soon as possible”.
“The prohibited funding case has been ongoing for eight years,” he had said. “The election law says that if a party takes money from a foreign individual, it has to be declared.”
Subsequently, the PTI announced to file a ‘judicial reference’ against CEC Sikander Sultan Raja and other members of the ECP for allegedly violating the code of conduct.
Imran announces 'peaceful protest' outside ECP
Meanwhile, PTI chief and former prime minister Imran Khan continued his tirade against the electoral body Monday and announced to hold a peaceful protest outside of the ECP on Thursday, demanding Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Sikandar Sultan Raja’s resignation.
Addressing the members at the PTI's national council meeting in the federal capital, he demanded that the election commission refrains from conducting the next general elections under any circumstances.
The party chairperson said that he will hold elections within his party after the general elections to ensure meritocracy.
The former prime minister said that he wanted electronic voting machines (EVMs) for free and fair elections but the chief election commissioner (CEC) tried every way possible to sabotage it.
"The ruling parties disagreed with holding elections through EVMs because they wanted to rig the elections. Before the by-elections in Punjab, our party was the only one preparing to stop the polls from getting rigged," he added.
A day earlier, the PTI chief had a day earlier formally directed his legal team to initiate the process of filing the reference against the CEC and ECP members for meeting a delegation of the ruling alliance and discussing the prohibited funding case against PTI with them.
SC judgment on foreign funding
The Supreme Court has already discussed in detail the question of foreign funding in its 2017 judgment on a petition filed by Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) leader Hanif Abbasi, who had sought the disqualification of Imran Khan.
The SC bench led by the former chief justice of Pakistan (CJP) Mian Saqib Nisar, while making a distinction between a ‘foreign aided’ party and ‘prohibited funding’, referred to the case on December 16, 2017, to the ECP for a probe.
The judgment noted that it is the duty of the ECP to scrutinise accounts of political parties on the touchstone of Article 6(3) of the PPO read in the light of Article 17(3) of the Constitution.
However, the apex court in its judgment had noted that it is not the case that the PTI was formed or organised at the instance of any government or political party of a foreign country or is affiliated to or associated with any government or political party of a foreign country, or receives any aid, financial or otherwise, from any government or political party of a foreign country.
Rather, the allegation is that the PTI has been receiving financial contributions and/or a portion of its funds from foreign nationals as not only the directors of the PTI USA LLC are American citizens, but contributions have been collected from individuals and the companies that are admittedly foreign nationals.
 
COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Pakistani delivery boy wins heart of Dubai crown prince over ‘heroic act’
Updated Aug 01, 2022
Copter with army general on board goes missing
Updated Aug 01, 2022
Aviation helicopter, which was on flood relief operations in Lasbela, lost contact with ATC, says ISPR
ECP says PTI received 'prohibited funds' from 34 foreign nationals
Updated 16 hours ago
PTI issued show cause notice in prohibited funding case
US drone strike kills al Qaeda chief Zawahiri in Afghanistan
Updated 22 hours ago
Two intelligence sources say Ayman al-Zawahiri was killed in a 'successful' counterterrorism operation
Being compared to me is not a curse: Mathira reacts to Kiran Tabier's comment
Updated Aug 01, 2022
The TV host took to her Instagram stories to question why people think call her out in a certain way
Pakistani delivery boy wins heart of Dubai crown prince over ‘heroic act’
Updated Aug 01, 2022
Copter with army general on board goes missing
Updated Aug 01, 2022
Aviation helicopter, which was on flood relief operations in Lasbela, lost contact with ATC, says ISPR
ECP says PTI received 'prohibited funds' from 34 foreign nationals
Updated 16 hours ago
PTI issued show cause notice in prohibited funding case
ECC okays Rs30b bailout to save PSO from default
Updated Aug 01, 2022
PSO international payments swell as petrol sales drop by 32%, rupee devalues against US dollar
PMD warns of ‘above-normal’ rainfall this month
Updated Aug 01, 2022
Army steps up relief effort in flood-hit Balochistan
Special body demanded to probe PTI funding
PTI meetings with election chief outnumber PDM’s
Damning report on PTI funding a godsend for beleaguered PML-N
Imran 'attacking' ECP fearing adverse verdict in foreign funding case: Maryam
Foreign funding case: PTI says ECP scrutiny panel ‘ignored’ its audits
Sindh Assembly urges ECP to announce foreign funding case verdict
Nawaz urges govt to ‘immediately take action against Imran’ after ECP verdict
Police charge UK man over crossbow threat to Queen
Pelosi defies China threats and lands in Taiwan
Pakistan played ‘absolutely no role’ in al Qaeda chief Zawahiri’s killing
Govt mulls imposing ban on PTI after ECP verdict
US has no DNA on Zawahiri, confirmed death by other sources: White House
Style Anatomy: Anjiya Mithani
Style 101: 9 Lines
One On One: Saadia Yasin Siddik and Miara Shaikh
Pakistani delivery boy wins heart of Dubai crown prince over 'heroic act'
Copter with army general on board goes missing
ECP says PTI received 'prohibited funds' from 34 foreign nationals
US drone strike kills al Qaeda chief Zawahiri in Afghanistan
Being compared to me is not a curse: Mathira reacts to Kiran Tabier's comment
How the CIA identified and killed Al-Qaeda leader Zawahiri
Visions of Mahbub
Takeaways from Bangladesh’s leadership
A bench-mark
Rethinking biotech investments
President Biden’s Middle East visit
Is the West punishing Pakistan because of China?
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed or derived from. Unless otherwise stated, all content is copyrighted © 2022 The Express Tribune.

source